Reviews of Witness in Bishop Hill

The prize here is the gently effective interpretation of the Alzheimer's scourge.
    -- Kirkus Reviews, Sept. 15, 2002

It's been much too long since the last Joan Spencer mystery and Sara Hoskinson Frommer has come up with a winner once again. Joan is a believable amateur sleuth with the ability to think things through while knowing what should be left up to the police. Frommer also gives us a delightful visit to a community grounded in old-world customs. I highly recommend this to all who love a good traditional mystery.
    -- Lelia Taylor, Creatures 'n Crooks Bookshoppe

When Joan and new husband Lt. Fred Lundquist travel to Bishop Hill for a belated honeymoon, the only witness to murder in the small Swedish-American community is Fred's Alzheimer's-afflicted mother in Witness in Bishop Hill, Sara Hoskinson Frommer's latest appealing Joan Spencer mystery. Expect plenty of cosy chills as Joan strives to prevent a vicious killer from striking again.
    -- Publishers Weekly, October 14, 2002

The care and handling of Alzheimer's victims is neatly enfolded into this tale, which also gently treats Swedish Christmas customs, the tender and fraught relationship between Joan's college-age son Andrew, his new step-father, and herself, and the long memories of small towns. Frommer is a brisk and clean writer, and she handles the rueful ambivalence of middle age very well indeed.
    -- GraceAnne A. DeCandido, Booklist, November 1, 2002, p. 447.

The village and its traditions spring to life from Frommer's crisp prose and her deft interweaving of serious social issues into the crime-solving elevate the book well above the typical cozy.
    -- (MGP) The Drood Review of Mystery, November/December 2002, p. 12.

Family dynamics and a Midwestern sensibility are the hallmarks of Sara Hoskinson Frommer's Joan Spencer series. So it's no surprise that the author delivers an insightful take on Alzheimer's disease and domestic issues in the well-plotted Witness in Bishop Hill. . . . Frommer keeps the plot on a steady course while realistically depicting the devastation of Alzheimer's. A heartbreaking recurring situation is that Helga, once a wiz in the kitchen, has forgotten how to cook, yet is always saying she needs to start dinner. Yet never once does Frommer stoop to a maudlin viewpoint in Witness in Bishop Hill. The author keeps her fifth novel briskly moving while capturing then charm of a small town.
    -- Oline H. Cogdill, South Florida Sun-Sentinel, January 19, 2003.

Return to home page